Skip to content

No Tax Evasion, Mens Rea Necessary for Penalty in GST, Allahabad High Court

In a recent case (M/s Hindustan Herbal Cosmetics v. State of U.P. & 2 others), Justice Shekhar B. Saraf, in WRIT TAX No. – 1400, delivered a significant ruling on tax evasion penalties, offering relief to businesses facing consequences for minor errors in their e-way bills.

Protecting Businesses from Unfair Penalties: A Breakdown


  • Hindustan Herbal Cosmetics, under scrutiny for a typographical error on their e-way bill (writing ‘3552’ instead of ‘5332’), faced accusations of tax evasion, leading to the imposition of a penalty.

Court’s Verdict:

  • The Allahabad High Court, underlining the principle that “mens rea for evasion of tax is a sine qua non for imposition of penalty,” declared the company’s mistake as a simple typo with no evidence of intentional tax evasion.

Key Developments:

  1. Typographical Error and Accusations:
  • Hindustan Herbal Cosmetics made a simple typo on their e-way bill, altering the truck number to ‘3552.’
  • Tax authorities, interpreting the mistake as an attempt to evade taxes, imposed a penalty on the company.
  1. Court’s Evaluation:
  • The Court, after careful consideration, concluded that there was no intentional evasion of taxes. The error was deemed a genuine typo without any deliberate wrongdoing.
  1. Ruling and Reimbursement:
  • Emphasizing that penalties should only apply in cases of clear intent to avoid tax payments, the Court overturned the penalty.
  • The tax authorities were directed to reimburse the company for the erroneously imposed penalty.

Implications for Businesses:

  • Intent Matters:
  • Penalties are justified only when there is a clear intention to evade taxes. Simple mistakes, like typographical errors, should not be subject to punishment.
  • Minor Errors Get a Break:
  • The Court acknowledges that small typos are inevitable, providing protection to businesses from penalties arising from honest mistakes.
  • Caution without Panic:
  • While this ruling offers a shield against automatic penalties for minor errors, businesses are reminded of the importance of accuracy in e-way bills. Major errors or repeated mistakes may still warrant penalties.

In Conclusion:
The Allahabad High Court’s ruling sets a precedent, highlighting the necessity of intent for the imposition of tax evasion penalties. This decision provides clarity and protection for businesses facing repercussions for inadvertent errors on their e-way bills.

At “Pro Legal Expert” we recognize the significance of staying informed about legal developments that impact businesses. As advocates registered with the Bar Council of Jammu Kashmir High Court and practicing at the Anantnag District Court, we are committed to offering exceptional legal services. Our deep understanding of the intricacies of various laws and procedures allows us to provide comprehensive legal solutions.

For individuals particularly in Jammu & Kashmir seeking guidance on legal matters, our online platform offers free legal assistance in a user-friendly manner. Whether you have concerns about tax compliance, business regulations, or any other legal issue, don’t hesitate to contact us via call or WhatsApp. Depend on Advocate Aid for reliable, insightful, and comprehensive legal solutions tailored to your specific needs.


The Bar Council of India does not permit advertisement or solicitation by advocates in any form or manner. By accessing this website,, you acknowledge and confirm that you are seeking information relating to Law Offices of Advocate Mushtaq Ahmad Dar of your own accord and that there has been no form of solicitation, advertisement or inducement by our Law Offices or its members. The content of this website is for informational purposes only and should not be interpreted as soliciting or advertisement. No material/information provided on this website should be construed as legal advice. The Law Offices ( shall not be liable for the consequences of any action taken by relying on the material/information provided on this website. The contents of this website are the intellectual property of Advocate Mushtaq Ahmad Dar.